O’Shea fined for false and misleading evidence to stewards

Clinton Payne - Wednesday August 30

Randwick trainer John O'Shea is free to continue training after stewards slapped him with a $30,000 penalty for his involvement in the Godolphin strangles affair.

Henry Plumptre and John O'Shea in happier times. Photo: Darryl Sherer

O'Shea was found guilty by stewards of having knowledge Polemic was infected with the highly contagious upper respiratory tract infection and providing false and/or misleading evidence to stewards.

At a sentencing hearing on Tuesday, O'Shea's legal counsel produced "a number of notable references provided from Mr John Messara AM, Mr Ron Finemore AO and Mr Richard Pegum, attesting to Mr O'Shea's good character".

When considering penalty stewards also took into account "a statement provided by Mr O'Shea detailing his personal and professional circumstances and a recognition that the matter 'could have been handled better'".

O'Shea was fined $10,000 for the charge under Australian rule of racing AR 175(I) - of being a party to (former Godolphin Australia managing director) Mr (Henry) Plumptre committing a breach of AR64K(2) for not reporting as soon as possible by the quickest means of communication available to Racing NSW, the Principal Racing Authority in NSW, that the racehorse Polemic was confirmed as being infected with the notifiable disease or condition strangles as required by AR64K(2) when he became aware that the racehorse Polemic was so infected, on 4 August 2016.

 

"The Stewards agree with the submissions of Mr (Matthew) Stirling (O'Shea's legal counsel) relative to the approach to be taken when considering Mr O'Shea's offence under this rule, specifically that Mr Plumptre was charged as the principal offender and Mr O'Shea was party to that offence," the stewards report read.

"The Stewards found that Mr Plumptre should be fined $20,000, which was reduced to $15,000 having regard to the established principal of a 25% reduction for his guilty plea and co-operation with the Stewards. In Mr O'Shea's case the Stewards have a not guilty plea."

He was fined a further $20,000 for the charge under Australian rule of racing AR 175 (g) - of providing false and/or misleading evidence at a Stewards interview on 16 June 2017 and Stewards inquiry on 26 June 2017 relative to his knowledge that Polemic was confirmed as having tested positive to the notifiable disease or condition strangles.

"Disqualification or suspension of licence have been a well-established punishment for serious breaches of the AR175(g) that impact upon the integrity of racing," the stewards report read.

"Mr (Matthew) Stirling (O'Shea's legal counsel) submitted that a period of disqualification or suspension was not appropriate in this case, as Mr O'Shea's offending was of a "moderate kind" for the following reasons;

  1. The level of materiality of Mr O'Shea's evidence, given that he admitted that he suspected that Polemic had strangles (with that suspicion being enough for him to be caught by AR64K(2), which reads "A person who…suspects or should reasonably suspect [that a horse] is infected with a notifiable disease or condition";
  2. Mr O'Shea's false and/or misleading evidence had no real consequence for the investigation, either in relation to him, other licensed persons, or others subject of the inquiry;
  3. The offence that was being concealed was not of the more serious kind that impacts upon the integrity of racing having regard to precedent penalties.

"In addition to the above, Mr Stirling raised a number of other factors that he maintained should be taken into account in mitigation, including Mr O'Shea's longstanding good record of over 20 years in the racing industry and his personal and professional circumstances."

The stewards conclusion to the penalty was, "The Stewards determine that a fine is the appropriate penalty in respect to this charge, having regard to the mitigating factors. The Stewards are, however, of the opinion that such fine must still send an appropriate message as detailed in the reasons for decision of Smith above. Accordingly, Mr O'Shea is fined the sum of $20,000.

"In issuing a fine as opposed to a period of suspension or disqualification, the Stewards emphasise that they consider that starting point for a penalty for a breach of this rule, particularly where it impacts significantly upon the integrity of racing and the ability of the Stewards to investigate and prosecute breaches of the Rules of Racing, is a period of disqualification or suspension and this decision should not be considered as a precedent for matters of that kind."

O'Shea was advised of his rights of appeal.


Advertisment
More Reading...
El Vencedor wins G3 Balmerino Stakes
El Vencedor is making a habit of picking up major victories at Ellerslie, adding the Gr.3 Balmerino Stakes (2000m) to his burgeoning record at Tuesday’s Melbourne Cup Day meeting.
Rosemont and Partners Stakes Quinella on Cup Day
Written Tycoon posted his second new stakes-winner on Melbourne Cup Day when promising three year-old gelding Catoggio took out the Listed VRC Amanda Elliot Stakes (1400m)  for Rosemont Stud and partners, who also race the second horse Bosustow.
Knights Choice a True Underdog Story
Punters were left stunned when the Queenslander Knight's Choice and Japanese visitor Warp Speed (JPN) emerged from the pack to fight out a dramatic finish to the $8,560,000 Group 1 Lexus Melbourne Cup (3200m) at Flemington.
Kiwi Bred Grey Wins Subzero for OTI at Flemington
New Zealand-bred gelding Cloudland proved a handful for James McDonald at Flemington on Tuesday, but the champion jockey was in a forgiving mood after they had claimed top honours in the Subzero Handicap.
Stewards find O’Shea guilty and fine Plumptre
Racing NSW stewards have handed down their findings in the Godolphin strangles case against former high-ranking employees, trainer John O’Shea and managing director Henry Plumptre.
All Too Hard's Arran Bay Brave in the Furphy Plate
Phillip Stokes admitted his preference was to run Arran Bay in the Listed John Letts Cup at Morphettville but was overruled by the owners, who made the correct decision in favouring the Listed Furphy Plate (1800m) at Flemington.
$6million Frankel Mare Tops Fasig -Tipton November Sale
The Fasig-Tipton November Sale, billed as the World’s Premier Breeding Stock Event, was held Monday at the company’s Newtown Paddocks in Lexington, Kentucky. Twenty-five offerings sold for $1,000,000 or more, led by a trio of Grade/Group 1 winners with international appeal.
2024 Melbourne Cup Result - It's Knights Choice
The 2024 Melbourne Cup has been run and won with Knight’s Choice, a five-year-old gelding by Extreme Choice victorious.
Kiwi Bred Gringotts Wins $3million Big Dance
Talented New Zealand-bred gelding Gringotts(NZ) (Per Incanto) delivered a big payday for his connections with victory in Tuesday’s A$3 million Big Dance (1600m) at Randwick.
More Stakes Success for Air Assault
Group I placed last season in the SA Derby, talented gelding Air Assault kept the winning run going for Victoria Derby winning trainer Andrew Gluyas when taking out the Listed SAJC John Letts Cup (1800m) at Morphettville on Melbourne Cup Day.