Does the Market Get it Right?

Tara Madgwick - Tuesday January 8
Our series on first season sires displaying their yearlings in a user friendly format so prospective buyers can get a real insight as to the overall type a sire is producing has been really well received, making us wonder just what sale ring success means at the Magic Millions for a first season sire – is it a passport to success or did the good judges get it wrong.

We've looked back through the last nine Magic Millions Yearling Sales back to 2010 looking at the leading first crop sires and where are they now.
Holy Roman Emperor
2010 – Holy Roman Emperor (IRE) led the averages by three or more sold with eight yearlings averaging $106,563. The fortunes of this Coolmore shuttler have waxed and waned, but essentially he's shown himself to be a high class sire of 79 stakes-winners worldwide.

He's just finished a season at Aquis Farm in Queensland and is now back at Coolmore in Ireland where he stands at a fee of 15,000 euros.

Interestingly in the 2010 list was Written Tycoon, who had one yearling at the Gold Coast fetch $45,000. That yearling became Trump, who would go on to become one of his first winners and also one of his first stakes-winners when winning the Group III BRC Gunsynd Classic at Doomben.

2011 – The Darley duo of Street Sense (USA) and Bernardini (USA)led the averages, the former with nine yearlings averaging $136,944 and the latter with 12 yearlings averaging $115,417.

Both sired Group I winners in this country, but neither were able to sustain lasting commercial success to warrant continued shuttling, although both remain on the Darley Kentucky roster. Bernardini stands at a fee of $US50,000 and Street Sense also at $US50,000.
Sebring
2012 – Was an interesting year as it marked the debut of Widden Stud's heavy hitters Sebring and Northern Meteor, but interestingly neither were the top first crop sire by average. That honour went to Darley shuttler New Approach (IRE), whose three yearlings averaged $172,500. He shuttled for just four seasons and remains on the UK Darley roster at a fee of 30,000 pounds.

For the record, Sebring had 26 yearlings average $154,423 and is now a well established leading sire, while Northern Meteor had 35 average $104,929. Northern Meteor went on to claim the title of Australian Champion First Season Sire, but died tragically after just four seasons at stud. His legacy is now secure with his brilliant son Zoustar dominating his peers and is among the most represented sires at the 2019 Magic Millions.

2013 – A Group I winning son of Fastnet Rock, Wanted was the clear leader with 11 yearlings averaging $149,773. His progeny failed to run up to their looks and Wanted has slipped from favour with commercial breeders, although did sire Leicester to win the Group I South Australian Derby last year.

I Am InvincibleFurther down the list with nine yearlings averaging $81,667 was Yarraman Park's bargain sire I Am Invincible, who was thought to have had a very good sale with his progeny coming off an $11,000 fee. This year he is the most represented sire at this sale and may well provide the sale-topper as he did last year.

2014 – Starspangledbanner was the leader with six yearlings averaging $127,500 while not far behind was Hinchinbrook with 13 yearlings averaging $123,077 and Star Witness with 18 averaging $112,9178. Starspangledbanner has had well documented fertility issues that have hampered his career, while Hinchinbrook (sadly deceased last year) and Star Witness have emerged as serious Group I sires.

2015 – Sepoy smashed it out of the park with 26 yearlings averaging $286,346, a phenomenal average for a first season horse. Sadly, his progeny race results did not reflect his sale ring success and Sepoy has just one yearling entered for the sale this year.

Runner-up was So You Think with 16 yearlings averaging $234,688. The ten time Group I winner has proven a reliable source of classic horses and Group I winners and has 21 entries in this year's sale.
Pierro
2016 – Pierro led the way with 37 yearlings averaging $262,568, just ahead of his arch rival All Too Hard with 38 yearlings averaging $221,842. Pierro had the wood on All Too Hard in the sale ring and has also had it over him on the track finishing as Champion First and then Second Season Sire with All Too Hard also doing a good job, just not as good as Pierro.

2017 – Dundeel set the standard with 10 yearlings averaging $272,500 over Zoustar next with 32 yearlings averaging $265,156. Dundeel is showing good promise as his progeny mature, but Zoustar has left him in the dust at this point in time and is showing all signs of being an outstanding stallion.

Spirit of Boom had six yearlings average $120,000 again a result seen as very positive for a stallion off a modest $11,000 fee.

2018 – Deep Field had 39 yearlings average $219,231 to top the averages over Kiwi base Charm Spirit ($216,250) and Dissident ($203,824). With seven months of the racing season to run anything can happen on the first season sires table, but at the moment only Deep Field features in the Top 5 and he's number five.


Better Than Ready had only two yearlings in Book One last year and they made $80,000 and $22,000, while his four Book Two yearlings averaged $43,000.




Advertisment
More Reading...
Antrim Coast to Fly Flag for The Oaks Stud
The well-renowned colours of The Oaks Stud will feature across two feature Trans-Tasman meetings this week, kicking off with Antrim Coast lining up in the Listed Furphy Plate (1800m) on Melbourne Cup Day at Flemington.
Knights Choice a True Underdog Story
Punters were left stunned when the Queenslander Knight's Choice and Japanese visitor Warp Speed (JPN) emerged from the pack to fight out a dramatic finish to the $8,560,000 Group 1 Lexus Melbourne Cup (3200m) at Flemington.
2024 Melbourne Cup Result - It's Knights Choice
The 2024 Melbourne Cup has been run and won with Knight’s Choice, a five-year-old gelding by Extreme Choice victorious.
Kiwi Bred Grey Wins Subzero for OTI at Flemington
New Zealand-bred gelding Cloudland proved a handful for James McDonald at Flemington on Tuesday, but the champion jockey was in a forgiving mood after they had claimed top honours in the Subzero Handicap.
Kiwi Bred Gringotts Wins $3million Big Dance
Talented New Zealand-bred gelding Gringotts(NZ) (Per Incanto) delivered a big payday for his connections with victory in Tuesday’s A$3 million Big Dance (1600m) at Randwick.
Sires With Winners - Tuesday November 5
Here is the full list of 145 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Rosemont and Partners Stakes Quinella on Cup Day
Written Tycoon posted his second new stakes-winner on Melbourne Cup Day when promising three year-old gelding Catoggio took out the Listed VRC Amanda Elliot Stakes (1400m)  for Rosemont Stud and partners, who also race the second horse Bosustow.
$6million Frankel Mare Tops Fasig -Tipton November Sale
The Fasig-Tipton November Sale, billed as the World’s Premier Breeding Stock Event, was held Monday at the company’s Newtown Paddocks in Lexington, Kentucky. Twenty-five offerings sold for $1,000,000 or more, led by a trio of Grade/Group 1 winners with international appeal.
Melbourne Cup Pedigree Analysis - Do It Yourself
Breednet has produced a great page with click through to five generation pedigrees for all the Melbourne Cup runners, so for amateur pedigree buffs looking to have a Cup flutter based pedigree here’s your chance  to DIY it!
El Vencedor wins G3 Balmerino Stakes
El Vencedor is making a habit of picking up major victories at Ellerslie, adding the Gr.3 Balmerino Stakes (2000m) to his burgeoning record at Tuesday’s Melbourne Cup Day meeting.