Lessons From The GFC For This Breeding Season

Craig Tompson - Thursday April 16

The world economy has collapsed, and many in the breeding industry are heading into a 2020 breeding season full of uncertainty about how the future will unfold so we thought we’d look at what happened the last time the world economy hit a hurdle.

That of course was the Global Financial Crisis in 2008/2009.

The foals conceived this season will be for sale in 2023, something of a cushion perhaps but clouded for breeders who are holding stock for sale in 2021 and 2022 off the back of service fees with their roots in growing sales results and a thriving racing industry.

It was only three months ago that the Magic Millions Gold Coast Yearling Sale returned the highest average and median in their history.

Two weeks ago, Inglis Easter returned stunning figures given the circumstances – a roughly 10% drop in average with an increase in median on last year but it is fooling nobody.

It was a testament to the work of Inglis and the vendors, aided by a vastly reduced elite quality catalogue to a vastly reduced buyers bench, but the Easter catalogue was 514 strong and 230 found a home.

No doubt some wished they hadn’t pulled out with quality stock, but the back story is a significant number of breeders have horses they couldn’t sell and/or have rolled the dice on an improvement by July, all with added holding costs and risk.

And for every one of those, there is two more thankful this crisis didn’t come earlier and probably wary because of it.

Imagine the carnage had COVID-19 come three months earlier – Magic Millions, Classic, Premier, Karaka and the rest.

Despite the pain of some post-Easter, we’ve overall dodged a bullet thus far but the future is uncertain so what does history tell us?

By March 2008 the Australian stock market had tanked to the tune of around 22% yet curiously the major yearling sales being run at the time were hitting new peaks.

12 months later the markets were down 50%, the economy was battered and the yearling market started to take it’s medicine.

We’ve split the yearling market into three divisions based on selling price: the top 5%, the next 10% and the next 25%, so the top 40% of yearlings which brings in the lower middle market through to the elite brigade.

Each bracket recovered at differing speeds with the top 5% taking the longest to get back to pre-GFC levels, however overall the yearling market correlates reasonably closely to the Australian Stock Market.

In 2008 the top 5% of yearlings averaged $521,000 with a median of $400,000.

In 2009 those numbers fell 35% to $334,000 and $260,000.

They did not get back to 2008 levels until 2016.

The next 10% averaged $158,000 in 2008 with a median price of $150,000.

In 2009 they fell to the tune of around 33% to $107,000 and $100,000.

The recovery for this upper middle market was much faster however, back to the $150,000 averages by 2011 where it plateaued for a few years before having a hot run in recent years, up from $151,000 in 2013 to $264,000 in 2019.

So those breeders operating in this sector of the market would have seen good market conditions for their yearlings produced off the GFC affected 2009 season, particularly given the overall drop in service fees for that year.

The next tier – those yearlings in the top 15% to 40% of the market averaged $60,000 in 2008 with a median of $57,500.

They took the biggest hit in 2009, down over 38% to an average of $37,000 and median of $35,000.

The recovery came much more quickly though. Two years later in 2011 the average was $69,000 and median $68,000.

So for those heading into the 2020 breeding season with some uncertainty and trepidation there would appear valid reason for optimism.

Whether it materialises or not, it would be foolish not to factor in a yearling market dip for 2021 which is going to hurt some with stock on the ground now, and the remainder of the yearling market and weanling market this year is going to be difficult at best.

At the time of writing the ASX has fallen around 36% since a February high but has recovered 19% in the last three weeks.

Whether that’s to be sustained or more pain is on the way is the current sixty four dollar question but again, at the time of writing, Australia’s coronavirus response is going well with increasing talk of re-opening the economy.

The speed of health and optimism returning to the yearling markets hinges closely on the fortunes of those overall markets but perhaps we got a bit lucky with the timing.

A quick recovery may see next year not too bad but given the lessons from the GFC, those sending mares to stallions this season have plenty of room to be confident they’ll be selling into recovered markets by the time they go to sale in 2023.

Advertisment
More Reading...
Kiwi Bred Grey Wins Subzero for OTI at Flemington
New Zealand-bred gelding Cloudland proved a handful for James McDonald at Flemington on Tuesday, but the champion jockey was in a forgiving mood after they had claimed top honours in the Subzero Handicap.
Sires With Winners - Tuesday November 5
Here is the full list of 145 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
All Too Hard's Arran Bay Brave in the Furphy Plate
Phillip Stokes admitted his preference was to run Arran Bay in the Listed John Letts Cup at Morphettville but was overruled by the owners, who made the correct decision in favouring the Listed Furphy Plate (1800m) at Flemington.
Melbourne Cup Pedigree Analysis - Do It Yourself
Breednet has produced a great page with click through to five generation pedigrees for all the Melbourne Cup runners, so for amateur pedigree buffs looking to have a Cup flutter based pedigree here’s your chance  to DIY it!
Antrim Coast to Fly Flag for The Oaks Stud
The well-renowned colours of The Oaks Stud will feature across two feature Trans-Tasman meetings this week, kicking off with Antrim Coast lining up in the Listed Furphy Plate (1800m) on Melbourne Cup Day at Flemington.
Sires With Winners - Monday November 4
Here is the full list of 21 stallions which had winners throughout Australasia today with winners and result details.
Magic Nick Strikes Again – Fastnet Rock x Galileo
The Fastnet Rock x Galileo nick has been on fire in Melbourne this spring producing Cox Plate winner Via Sistina (IRE) and leading Melbourne Cup contender Buckaroo (GB) and it struck again overnight in the UK with a brand new stakes-winner in Military Academy, who captured the Listed Floodlit Stakes (1m4f) at Kempton.
More Stakes Success for Air Assault
Group I placed last season in the SA Derby, talented gelding Air Assault kept the winning run going for Victoria Derby winning trainer Andrew Gluyas when taking out the Listed SAJC John Letts Cup (1800m) at Morphettville on Melbourne Cup Day.
$6million Frankel Mare Tops Fasig -Tipton November Sale
The Fasig-Tipton November Sale, billed as the World’s Premier Breeding Stock Event, was held Monday at the company’s Newtown Paddocks in Lexington, Kentucky. Twenty-five offerings sold for $1,000,000 or more, led by a trio of Grade/Group 1 winners with international appeal.
2024 Melbourne Cup Result - It's Knights Choice
The 2024 Melbourne Cup has been run and won with Knight’s Choice, a five-year-old gelding by Extreme Choice victorious.